Treatments, and telling real from fake

Plenty of crystals on the market have been altered, and plenty aren't what they're sold as. Neither is a problem if you're told. This is what the common treatments actually are, how to spot them, and how to tell a natural piece from a treated one or an outright fake.

Treated is not the same as fake

Two different things get confused constantly. A treated stone is real material that's been altered; heated, dyed, irradiated, or stabilised. A fake is something sold as a mineral it isn't, or as mineral when it's glass or plastic. One is a real crystal with something done to it. The other is a lie about what the thing is.

Treatment isn't the problem. Most of it is long-established, accepted, and sometimes the only way certain material reaches the market at all. The problem is undisclosed treatment; paying natural prices for altered material because nobody told you. So the rule is simple. We state treatment on every piece, and this page tells you what those treatments are.

The treatments you'll actually encounter

  • Heating

    The most common treatment of all, and one of the oldest. Controlled heat deepens or changes colour; most commercial citrine is heat-treated amethyst, and a great deal of "natural" colour in the trade has had heat applied. It's stable and permanent. Often impossible to detect by eye, which is exactly why disclosure matters.

  • Dyeing

    Colour added from outside, rather than changed from within. Common on porous, pale, or banded material; agate, howlite, magnesite, quartz. The tells: colour pooled in cracks and fractures, unnaturally uniform or vivid shades, and dye visible where the stone is chipped. Much bright "turquoise" is dyed howlite or magnesite.

  • Irradiation

    Radiation used to produce or intensify colour; deep blues, smoky and black tones, some intense greens. The material is safe once it reaches you. Like heating, it's usually undetectable by eye, so you rely entirely on the seller knowing and saying.

  • Stabilisation and coating

    Soft or fragile material impregnated with resin to harden it, or surface-coated for shine or colour effects. Common on softer turquoise and on the iridescent "aura" quartzes, which are metal-coated. Coatings show as colours no natural quartz produces; the rainbow metallics are almost always treated, and that's fine as long as it's named.

  • Heating

  • Dyeing

  • Irradiation

  • Coating

Treated isn't the problem. Hidden is.

How to tell natural from treated

Start with plausibility. Ask whether the colour you're looking at occurs naturally in that mineral at that intensity. Vivid blue quartz, jet-black "obsidian" points that are too glassy, neon-bright agate slices; these are colours nature rarely or never produces in that species, and a colour that shouldn't exist is your first flag. Knowing what a mineral's natural colour range actually is does more than any test.

Then check the price against the claim. Fine natural colour is rare and priced accordingly. A deep, even, "perfect" colour at a low price is usually telling you it was helped; genuinely top natural material doesn't sell cheap. Price that seems too good for the colour on offer is information.

Then look closely at the surface and the breaks. Dye collects in cracks and concentrates along fractures; run your eye over any chips or natural openings and look for colour that's pooled rather than grown. Coatings sit on top of the stone and scratch or wear at the edges, and produce metallic sheens no mineral makes.

What none of this catches is heating and irradiation. Both change the material from within and leave no surface trace; there is no fingertip test, and anyone who tells you they can always spot heated citrine by eye is overselling. For these, you are relying entirely on the seller knowing the treatment and stating it. That isn't a gap in your skill; it's the limit of what any eye can do, and the precise reason disclosure isn't optional.

And how to tell real from fake

Fakes are a different check, and often an easier one. Glass sold as quartz gives itself away; air bubbles trapped inside, a warmth to the touch that quartz doesn't have, and colours too uniform to be natural. Plastic is lighter than it should be and warmer still. Reconstituted material; ground-up stone bound with resin and pressed into shape; shows an even, speckled texture without the natural patterning of the real thing.

Weight, temperature, and a careful look at the surface catch most fakes. The eye that knows what real material looks like is the best tool there is, which is the skill the rest of these guides are built to give you.

Know what you own.

What disclosure looks like on a listing

Every piece we sell states its treatment status in plain terms; natural, or exactly what's been done to it. Not buried, not implied, not left for you to work out from the price. If a stone has been heated, dyed, irradiated, or coated, the listing says so.

This is the part most sellers leave vague, because "natural-looking" sells better than "dyed." We'd rather tell you and lose the sale than sell you something you misunderstood. A treated stone honestly described is a fair purchase; a treated stone sold as natural is not.

Keep learning

  • Collector's guide

    The four factors that decide what a specimen is worth.

  • How to read a specimen

    What to look at, in order, before you buy.

  • Our grading system explained

    What hand-selected, batch-inspected and quality-approved mean.

  • Where it comes from

    Why a documented origin matters, and what it adds to a piece.

Treated or natural, you'll always know which

Every piece we sell states its species, documented locality, and treatment status plainly. Natural where it's natural, and exactly what's been done where it hasn't. No stone sold as something it isn't.